Benjamin Scafidi and Eric Wearne, Education Economics Center, Kennesaw State University
June 2021
This is the June 2021 beta, or pre-release, ECER. It has been superseded by ECER 2022 and ECER 2024.
Summary
In this June 2021 concept paper, Benjamin Scafidi and Eric Wearne of the Education Economics Center at Kennesaw State University propose ranking state charter school ecosystems by student outcomes: charter school access and academic performance. The authors contrast this approach with rankings by the National Association of Charter School Authorizers (NACSA) and NAPCS, which judge states on fidelity to policies favored by experts.
This Beta version of the EFI Charter Ecosystem Rankings (ECER) combines charter enrollment share, the share of students living in a ZIP code with a charter school, and value-added gains in reading and math. The access measures use 2013-14 data reported by The Hamilton Project and Brookings, and most performance estimates come from CREDO data up through 2010-11. Data limits allowed the authors to rank 30 states, including Washington, DC.
The District of Columbia placed in the top three on all four components, Michigan placed between 4th and 8th on each, and Rhode Island, the third-rated state, placed first for test score growth in both subjects. Nevada ranked lowest in reading and math, and Washington last on both access measures.
The authors call this a Beta version because its data are dated and limited, and they describe its purpose as demonstrating the concept of ranking states on outcomes. They planned later versions built on more contemporary data, so this page describes the original 2021 framework only.
Key findings
The June 2021 Beta ECER ranks 30 states, including DC, on two charter access measures and on charter students’ reading and math growth, using 2013-14 access data and largely older CREDO estimates. DC placed in the top three on every component. The authors present it as a proof of concept built on dated data.
Questions and answers
How is this different from NACSA and NAPCS rankings?
Those rankings score states on how closely their policies match expert recommendations. This paper ranks states on charter access and student learning gains.
Why is it called a Beta version?
It relies on easily accessible data that the authors describe as dated and limited.
Why are only 30 states ranked?
Some states had no charter schools, and some did not share test score data with CREDO.
Is this the current ECER?
No. This is the original 2021 concept paper. The authors outlined future versions using more contemporary data.
Should charter laws be ranked by inputs or outcomes?
This beta report ranks 30 state charter ecosystems on access and academic growth in order to demonstrate an outcome-based alternative to input-based law rankings such as those from NACSA and NAPCS. In this edition, Washington, DC ranks first, followed by Michigan, Rhode Island and Louisiana, while Indiana, first in the NACSA and NAPCS rankings, places 19th of 30. These are ecosystem ranks, not ranks of individual schools, and the data are dated relative to the later ECER editions.
Read the paper
Read the full report (PDF): Inputs or Outcomes? Ranking State Charter School Ecosystems
Cite this study
Scafidi, Benjamin, and Eric Wearne. (June 2021). Inputs or Outcomes? Ranking State Charter School Ecosystems. An Educational Freedom Institute Concept Paper. Educational Freedom Institute. https://www.efinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/EFI-CharterEcosystemRankings_PreRelease.pdf
